Finance

Schonfeld's strong start to 2024 has the once imperiled manager besting larger peers

Steven Schonfeld, Ryan Tolkin, Andrew Fishman
Steven Schonfeld with Ryan Tolkin, left, and Andrew Fishman, right. Michael Nagle/Getty
Read in app

Less than half a year ago, the discussion around Schonfeld Strategic Advisors was about who would remain at the firm after its larger rival Millennium bought the onetime family office.

After finding large institutional investors to pledge billions, Schonfeld rejected Millennium's takeover offer and trimmed its headcount by more than 10%. Its performance has improved substantially.

The $10 billion manager returned 1.5% last month in its flagship fund, pushing its 2024 returns to 3.3% for the year, sources close to the firm told Business Insider. Its smaller fundamental equity fund gained 1.6% in February and is up 3% in 2024.

A Schonfeld representative declined to comment.

A source familiar with the firm said exposure to quant and tactical strategies, as well as trading in Asia, had been key to the outperformance, but Schonfeld has also been helped along as new traders hired in 2023 get up and running.

Since September, when Schonfeld was drumming up cash and cutting costs, the firm has returned 6.2% in its flagship fund and 7.4% in fundamental equity. Investors who wagered that Schonfeld would right the ship are looking brighter by the month.

Its 2024 performance to date has the New York-based manager leading its multistrategy peers, including Millennium and Ken Griffin's Citadel. Millennium, after a 0.2% gain in February, is up 1.6% so far this year, while Citadel's flagship Wellington fund has made 2.3% in 2024 after a 0.4% gain last month.

Steve Cohen's Point72, meanwhile, is up 2.8% in 2024 after a 1% gain in February. At the back of the pack are Balyasny and ExodusPoint, each of which is up 1% on the year, sources say.

Balyasny, which trailed peers in 2023, was flat last month, while Michael Gelband's ExodusPoint was up 0.7%.

Schonfeld's competition at the top has so far come from smaller peers this year. Sculptor Capital's $8.5 billion Master Fund was up 3.8% through February, while Minnesota-based Walleye — which has plans to expand — gained 3.7% over the same time period.

Here's a rundown of some of the large multimanager returns through February:

Fund

2024 performance

Sculptor Master Fund

3.8%

Walleye

3.7%

Schonfeld Strategic Partners

3.3%

Schonfeld Fundamental Equity

3%

Point72

2.8%

Citadel Wellington

2.3%

Verition

2.3%

Millennium

1.6%

Balyasny

1%

ExodusPoint

1%

Representatives for the firms declined to comment or did not respond to requests for comment.

Correction: March 5, 2024 — An earlier version of this story misstated the period for some of the returns represented in this story. The performance figures listed are for 2024, not 2023.

Read next

Bradley Saacks
Bradley Saacks
Bradley Saacks covers hedge funds and other asset managers for Business Insider from New York. He first wrote about the multi-trillion-dollar industry for Business Insider from New York in late 2018, after spending two years covering mutual funds for the Financial Times' trade publication, Ignites.He left Business Insider for a little over a year, starting in mid-2022, and worked as a business reporter for Semafor, a media startup. He rejoined Business Insider in 2023, this time in the publication's London office, and has since relocated back to New York. A graduate of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill's School of Media and Journalism, he was the recipient of the O.J. Skipper Coffin Award, which is given to the top graduating senior in the reporting track.During his time at Business Insider, he has broken news on the biggest names in hedge funds, including Paul Singer's Elliott Management, Ken Griffin's Citadel, Seth Klarman's Baupost Group, and more. He is interested in telling stories about the people behind the scenes who are driving big changes at the biggest firms. He can be reached on WhatsApp and Signal at +1 919 816 5537.Notable stories include:
Photo of Alex Morrell
Alex Morrell
Alex Morrell was a senior correspondent at Business Insider covering Wall Street at large.Prior to Insider he was a staff reporter at Forbes Magazine covering billionaires and their businesses. He's previously written and worked for the Associated Press, the Green Bay Press-Gazette, the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, and the Wisconsin Center for Investigative Journalism. He's a graduate of the University of Wisconsin and holds a master's in business and economic journalism from Columbia University. Selected recent stories:How our insatiable appetite for electricity is giving rise to traders who make money from power-grid bottlenecksBehind a Wall Street headhunter's rapid ascent lie accusations of harassment and abuseSchonfeld's growing pains: Ryan Tolkin reckons with his greatest challenge yet as returns dry up at the $13 billion hedge fundHow a California hedge fund bulldozed the state's labor laws to impose some of the harshest noncompetes on Wall StreetFear and loathing on Wall Street: Inside the paranoid, hyper-competitive onslaught to prevent quant traders from defecting to rivalsMillennium has quietly minted billions off of America's passive-investing craze. Now rivals are racing to catch up.The bubble has popped on the mighty index-rebalance trade, and the overcrowded strategy is wreaking carnage across hedge fundsInside the rapid rise and fall of Coatue's quant fund: How a 23-year-old Wharton wunderkind seized power, alienated employees, and blew a $350 million opportunityFor years, Chase and Citi credit cards offered a generous, under-the-radar benefit that protected customers. And then the bots arrived.